Forest Park City Council Votes Against Reinstating Police Chief Brandon Criss Despite Judge’s Ruling
FOREST PARK, GA — A contentious dispute over leadership of the Forest Park Police Department has taken another turn after the Forest Park City Council voted against reinstating former Police Chief Brandon Criss, despite a recent court ruling supporting the mayor’s authority to veto the council’s earlier action involving his termination.
During the November 16 City Council meeting, council members voted 3–2 against a motion to return Criss to his position. The decision followed a lengthy public discussion, strong reactions from residents, and a closed-door executive session with the city’s legal counsel.

The vote leaves unresolved a controversy that has divided city leadership and prompted questions about how the city will proceed following the court’s decision.
How the Dispute Began
The controversy dates back to February 2026, when Criss was placed on administrative leave following allegations involving his use of paid time off.
According to reporting by FOX 5 Atlanta and WSB Radio, an independent investigation subsequently cleared Criss of wrongdoing, determining that the disputed days involved dates when city offices were closed.
Nevertheless, Criss was terminated in May, and the City Council voted to uphold the termination.
Mayor Dr. Gwendolyn Webb Ellison vetoed the council’s action, but Criss was not permitted to return to his position.
The disagreement eventually moved into the courts, where a Clayton County judge ruled that the mayor had the authority to exercise her veto in the matter.
Council Members Split Over Reinstatement
At the November 16 meeting, Council Members Hector Gutierrez and Latresa Wells supported reinstating Criss.
Council Members Dolores Gunn, Kimberly James, and Alan Mears opposed the motion.
The 3–2 vote followed an executive session during which council members consulted with the city attorney.
According to FOX 5 Atlanta, Gunn expressed a desire to receive additional legal guidance regarding the court’s ruling before proceeding.
Council Member Mears subsequently indicated that the city would likely appeal the decision.
An appeal, however, had not been confirmed in the reporting reviewed for this article.
Mayor Calls for Respecting the Legal Process
Mayor Ellison has expressed concern about the council’s handling of the matter and the potential consequences for city residents.
In comments reported by 11Alive, the mayor emphasized that elected officials have a responsibility to respect judicial decisions and uphold the rule of law, regardless of whether they agree with the outcome.
Her position underscores a central question surrounding the controversy: How should the city respond when its governing officials disagree about the legal authority behind a personnel decision?
For residents, the dispute extends beyond the employment status of one police chief. It also involves confidence in municipal leadership, transparency in public decision-making, and the potential financial consequences of continued litigation.
What Happens Next?
The November 16 vote did not resolve the legal dispute.
Questions remain about whether the city will appeal the court’s ruling, whether additional legal proceedings will follow, and what steps may ultimately determine Criss’s employment status.
The controversy has also drawn attention to the costs associated with prolonged legal disagreements involving city officials.
Those costs, along with the operational implications for the police department, remain important matters for public scrutiny.
A Community Watching Its Leadership
Forest Park residents deserve clarity about how their city government operates, particularly when disagreements involve public safety leadership and decisions that could carry financial consequences for taxpayers.
The latest council vote illustrates the continuing divisions among elected officials and the challenges facing the city as it works through the dispute.
As the situation develops, residents will be looking for transparency, legal clarity, and a resolution that supports the stability of the Forest Park Police Department.
The Best of Clayton County will continue following this story, including any subsequent court proceedings, City Council actions, and developments affecting public safety leadership in Forest Park.
For additional Clayton County news, community developments, and local government coverage, visit www.BestofClaytonCounty.com.
Sources and additional reporting:






























Comments